City
Average Rent in Middle Island, New York
Middle Island is a city in New York. It ranks #169 out of 536 for places to rent. Middle Island is in
the county of
Suffolk County and the metropolitan area of
New York-Northern New Jersey-Long Island, NY-NJ-PA MSA. Dwellsy has rental data for Middle Island includes the zip code of
11953, no sections, no neighborhoods and no rental communities with places to rent.The average rent over the last 3 months for places in Middle Island is $2,500 which represents a decrease of -40% over the same period.
The most expensive zip code in Middle Island to rent places is 11953 with an average rent of $2,500. The least expensive zip code in Middle Island to rent places is 11953 with an average rent of $2,500.
Rental Price Comparison
The average rent for places in city Middle Island currently stands at $2,500.
In comparison, places in the largest zip, specifically 11953, is about the same cost, with an average rent of $2,500. This represents no difference when compared to Middle Island.
Meanwhile, in the average state of New York, the average rent for the same type of housing is $2,906, showing a more expensive of +16% from our subject location.
On a national scale, the average rent for a similar places across the United States is $1,859. This constitutes a less expensive by -26% when compared to the rent in Middle Island.
$2,500
Middle Island
VS$2,500
11953, zip
$2,906
+16%
NY, state
$1,859
-26%
USA, us
Average price for rental listings over the last 3 months. Last updated May 31 2026
Zip Codes in Middle Island, NY
11953$2,500
